The comparison scores every group at once. This page is for the moment you already have a pair of names in mind — mayfly or stonefly, scud or sowbug, shad or alewife — and want the structures that keep them apart, in one look. Nothing here is a current hatch.
The differences, and nothing else
Best separating check: Portable case or case-like structureAt a glance It partly separates 0 of the 1 pairs still in play and you can check it at a glance.
What to look at
Scud / Amphipod
Caddisfly
Reported size
5–20 mm
3–40 mm
Water it is recorded in
river, stream, lake margin, spring
river, stream, lake margin
Life stages covered
adult
larva, pupa, adult
How it moves
swims on its side (sideswimmer); rapid darting
crawling with case; swimming pupa
Reference seasonality
No family-level window
Emergence: Sep, Oct, Nov
Rows come from the reviewed diagnostic weights the comparison scores with. “Decisive” means one answer puts them at least four points apart — the carrier's own rule for a structure that separates a pair.
The two entries, side by side
Amphipoda · Crustacea — not Insecta
Scud / Amphipod
Not an insect, not a hatch, and the most common false positive there is.
First check
Watch it swim. On its side means scud, and you can stop there.
What it is
This entry exists to stop a wrong call, not to make a right one. Scuds are amphipod crustaceans. They are not insects, they do not hatch, and they never emerge — so a scud can never be the answer to what is coming off the water.
Stages
Adult amphipod (5–20 mm (most under 13 mm))
Water
river, stream, lake-margin, spring
Separates from Caddisfly
No case, no hardened head against a soft abdomen, and no terminal hooks. Just a curved, side-flattened crustacean.
Typical windows
No family-level window in this layer.
Patterns (correspondence)
Scud
Limits
Scuds are crustaceans, not insects. This entry exists solely to stop a scud being called a mayfly, caddis, or stonefly nymph.
Not every caddis builds a house, and the ones that don't are the ones you miss.
First check
Ignore the case. Look for a hard dark head against a soft pale abdomen, and hooks at the back end.
What it is
Caddis is the group most often identified by a thing that is only sometimes there. The portable case — grains of sand, cut leaf, twig fragments, spun into a tube the larva carries — is the classic image, and when you find one the call is easy. But a large share of caddis larvae never build a portable case at all. Free-living forms hunt loose among the rocks; net-spinners build a fixed retreat with a catch-net beside it and leave the retreat behind when disturbed.
Stages
Larva (3–40 mm (often 13–25 mm with case)) · Pupa (No source consulted gives a pupal size) · Adult (4–38 mm)
Water
river, stream, lake-margin
Separates from Scud / Amphipod
This entry does not name Scud / Amphipod as a look-alike. That is a gap in the prose, not proof they cannot be confused.
Typical windows
Larvae present (larva) · Emergence (pupa)
Patterns (correspondence)
Elk Hair Caddis · X-Caddis · Sparkle Pupa · Green Rock Worm · Peeking Caddis
Limits
Case-building behavior varies and absence of a visible case does not rule out caddis.
